Mesothelioma Settlements vs Verdicts

Mesothelioma, a rare but aggressive cancer primarily caused by asbestos exposure, brings not only severe health challenges but also significant financial burdens. For those affected, seeking justice and compensation through legal means is often a crucial step.

Mesothelioma Settlements and Verdicts

In the legal arena, mesothelioma compensation can be sought through settlements or verdicts. Both paths offer different processes and potential outcomes, each with its own advantages and risks.

Mesothelioma Settlements involve an agreement between the plaintiff and the defendant. This agreement is reached outside of court and is negotiated by the plaintiff's attorney. The settlement amount is a compromise that the defendant agrees to pay in exchange for the plaintiff dropping the lawsuit. Settlements are legally binding, which means that if the defendant fails to pay as agreed, legal action can be taken to enforce the payment. The certainty of a settlement can be appealing, as it guarantees compensation without the unpredictability of a trial.

Mesothelioma Verdicts are decided by a jury or judge after a trial. The jury determines the amount of damages based on the evidence presented. While verdicts can often result in higher awards than settlements, they come with the risk of appeals from the defendant, which could reduce the award amount or overturn it entirely. The trial process can be lengthy and emotionally taxing, but it provides a public forum to present your case and hold the responsible parties accountable.

Average Settlement and Verdict Amounts

The financial compensation in mesothelioma cases varies widely based on numerous factors, including the severity of the illness, the strength of the evidence, and the level of negligence by the defendant.

Settlement Amounts: On average, mesothelioma settlements range from $1 million to $2 million. This range reflects the amount of money typically awarded to plaintiffs in settlement agreements. The exact amount can fluctuate based on the specifics of the case, including the degree of fault by the defendant and the impact of the illness on the plaintiff’s life.

Verdict Amounts: Mesothelioma verdicts tend to be higher on average, ranging from $5 million to $11.4 million. These amounts are determined by the jury and can be influenced by factors such as the severity of the disease, the defendant's conduct, and the extent of the damages suffered. Notable cases have resulted in verdicts significantly exceeding these averages.

High-Profile Mesothelioma Lawsuit Settlements and Verdicts

Several landmark mesothelioma cases have brought to light the potential for substantial financial awards. Here are some notable examples:

• U.S. Steel Case (2003): U.S. Steel was ordered to pay $250 million to the widow of a former steel worker who succumbed to mesothelioma. Although a post-verdict settlement for a lesser amount was ultimately reached, this case remains one of the largest asbestos verdicts ever awarded.

• Johnson & Johnson Case (2018): Stephen Lanzo III and his wife were awarded $117 million after a jury found Johnson & Johnson and Imerys Talc America liable for selling asbestos-contaminated talcum powder, which led to Lanzo’s mesothelioma diagnosis.

• Ed Robaey Case (2017): In New York's largest single asbestos verdict, auto mechanic Ed Robaey was awarded $75 million for developing mesothelioma from working with asbestos gaskets in car engines.

• Robert Whalen Case (2014): A California jury awarded $70.8 million to Navy veteran Robert Whalen, who developed mesothelioma due to exposure to asbestos-containing products during his 26 years of naval service.

• Alfred D’Ulisse Case (2006): DaimlerChrysler was ordered to pay $25 million to Alfred D’Ulisse, a retired police officer and brake specialist who developed mesothelioma from exposure to asbestos in automobile brakes.

• George Lucas Case (2018): Longshoreman George Lucas received $24.26 million for mesothelioma caused by asbestos exposure during his nearly 30 years of working in San Francisco Bay shipyards.

Factors Influencing Mesothelioma Settlement and Verdict Amounts

Several key factors affect the amounts awarded in mesothelioma settlements and verdicts:

• Severity of Diagnosis: The extent of the plaintiff’s illness, including how advanced the mesothelioma is, plays a significant role in determining the compensation amount.

• Negligence of the Defendant: Evidence of the defendant’s negligence or wrongdoing significantly impacts the outcome. Strong evidence proving that the defendant’s actions or inactions directly contributed to the asbestos exposure can lead to higher settlements or verdicts.

• Medical Expenses and Lost Wages: The cost of medical treatments and the loss of income due to the illness are crucial factors. Settlements and verdicts often aim to cover these financial burdens comprehensively.

• Number of Defendants: When multiple companies are involved, it can influence the settlement negotiations. Sometimes, defendants may settle early to avoid the complexities of a multi-defendant trial.

• Jurisdiction: The state or jurisdiction in which the case is filed affects the legal process, including the amount of evidence required and the caps on damages that may apply.

The Settlement Process

The process of reaching a mesothelioma settlement involves several stages:

1. Filing the Claim: The legal process begins with filing a mesothelioma lawsuit. The defendants have a specified period to respond to the claim, and some may offer a settlement immediately.

2. Discovery: During this phase, both parties gather evidence, including medical records, employment history, and expert testimonies. This phase often leads to settlement negotiations, as defendants may prefer to settle rather than face the uncertainties of a trial.

3. Negotiation: Settlement negotiations can occur before, during, or after the discovery phase. Skilled attorneys use the evidence gathered to negotiate a fair settlement amount.

4. Trial and Appeal: If a settlement cannot be reached, the case goes to trial. If the jury awards damages, defendants may appeal the decision. Settlements can still be negotiated during or after the trial, especially if the verdict is unfavorable to the defendant.

Settlement Payment Options

Once a settlement is reached, plaintiffs can receive their compensation in one of two primary ways:

• Lump Sum Payment: This involves receiving the entire settlement amount in a single payment. It offers immediate financial relief but may not account for future expenses.

• Structured Settlement: This option involves receiving payments over time, providing a steady income stream. It can offer long-term financial stability but may lack flexibility for unforeseen expenses.

Common Questions About Mesothelioma Settlements

• Are Settlements Taxable? Typically, mesothelioma settlements are not taxable. However, compensation for lost wages or emotional distress might be subject to taxation.

• Who Receives Compensation in Wrongful Death Cases? In wrongful death settlements, compensation is usually awarded to the deceased’s estate and distributed according to the case’s specifics.

• What Are The Legal Fees? Mesothelioma attorneys often work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they are paid a percentage of the settlement or verdict. If no compensation is awarded, there are generally no legal fees.

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Name *

Email *

Comment *

---

Also in Personal Injury Blog